Edgardo's Questions...Well Sorta

[Edgardo Rivera]

Well Congrats girls! I am usually mean to the jury and slightly bitter in my remarks but I think the rest of these guys have covered that for me....and Jenna still hasn't gone .

Candice- I just want you to know why I made that comment to Fabio. Although you and Fabio may have had a good relationship because he was loyal to you but he sure as hell was not loyal to me. It was obvious he leaked all the info I trusted in him and he did a lot of pointless lying with me. I very much understand the idea of lying in a game but lying in the amount he did was unnecessary. What you also didn't see was the PM asking me to keep him which was just funny to me because the night before we had gotten into it. I have to say there was also some jury thought with the comment seeing as I knew the jury hated you 4 and so that snide remark just helped me.

Now to the questions..


I tried to talk to all of you about voting Brady at final 9/8. You all seemed to want Brady out at some point as well and you eventually did get rid of him. Why did you all refuse to jump on board with my plan?

How much power did Brady/Fabio have when it came to your decision making throughout the game?

Finale if the cast from Jenna on was playing real survivor what do you think the boot order would have been and why? Base this solely on the persons game play, no previous alliances or anything just as if we were starting the game.

[Fabio Birza]

Finale? You mean F-I-N-A-L-L-Y?

[Erinn Lobdell]

Hey Edgardo
I tried to talk to all of you about voting Brady at final 9/8. You all seemed to want Brady out at some point as well and you eventually did get rid of him. Why did you all refuse to jump on board with my plan?
we wanted to get Brady out,but we saw Sydney as a bigger threat than Brady
that's why we voted her out first and then we voted Brady

can you explain the other questions more coz I don't understand them

[Kelly Czarnecki]

1) I remember our talk and at the time I felt you were asking for us to vote out one of our alliance at a time when it would have given the other alliance the majority at the next vote. I knew you were playing both sides and was very careful to watch that you were never in a position to be the swing vote between the two alliances.

2) While Brady and Fabio put themselves in a position of being the voice of the alliance, going back and forth between the sides, of the two Brady had more control over votes than Fabio. Many of my conversations with Brady and Fabio involved them asking my opinion and us coming to an agreement on who the vote should be. We would discuss the risks and what we felt was the best direction to go for each round. Usually Brady would then contact the other 2 guys, Edgardo and Fabio and I would talk to Candice and Erinn. With Fabio he and I talked a lot, sometimes after he and Candice had talked, other times before. But I never felt that decisions were completely set and that I was being told how to vote.

3) I think if this cast came together for the real game the boot order would be much different as there are obviously some very strong guys on jury that could have easily won immunity challenges.
Erinn - You've drawn a lot of negative attention, and I'm afraid people will not tolerate that in a camp.
Fabio - because he seemed to upset people easily in the game so living in camp with him may be difficult for some. I think he may have gotten an early boot.
Marty - Possibly the older person in the group, often draws an early target.
Edgardo - If he was caught early in his plans to try to play both sides or someone didn't appreciate his sarcasm, he could end up getting voted early.
Empress Jenna - While I know she should never be forced into doing the daily tasks around camp, I'm afraid others may not feel that way and they may want to vote her out just because she is too beautiful for such menial tasks.
Kelly - Voted out because the guys have decided to go to the end
Candice - She is a challenge threat and gets voted out on a round when she doesn't win immunity.
Sydney - Gets voted out next. An idol that no one expected comes into play and unfortunately she is the victim of a blindside.
Benry becomes the last one voted out because everyone knows he would be dangerous to take to the end.
Charlie doesn't get voted out, he is part of a F3 with Brady and Jeff.

Thanks Edgardo and good luck as you decide how you will vote. If I need to clarify anything or you have other questions, just let me know.

[Edgardo Rivera]

Jan 27, 2011 3:27:42 GMT -5 Erinn Lobdell said:

Hey Edgardo


can you explain the other questions more coz I don't understand them

Kelly got them, just explain how much power the two guys had in your decisions and then rank the everyone if we came onto an island to play right now without knowing each other how do you think the order would go

[Candice Woodcock]

Hey Edgardo! Thanks for the congrats and for clearing up your comment. I obviously didn't know any of that so now I can understand.

I tried to talk to all of you about voting Brady at final 9/8. You all seemed to want Brady out at some point as well and you eventually did get rid of him. Why did you all refuse to jump on board with my plan?

I refused your plan because at the time, I wanted to stay loyal to Brady and wanted our alliance to make it to the end. It actually made me want to take you out first but we needed your vote for a few rounds. I had no intentions on turning on Brady but things did change as you saw. We eventually did vote him out because of being paranoid (thanks tomb) and he was controlling.

How much power did Brady/Fabio have when it came to your decision making throughout the game?

Both of them were big contributors in the decisions. I think at the beginning of the merge Brady had a lot of power. He managed to get people to vote a certain way and he was looking like a threat. Around F8 is when Brady started to lose his power and that's when Fabio started to have more of it but that is also when me/Kelly basically took control.

Finale if the cast from Jenna on was playing real survivor what do you think the boot order would have been and why? Base this solely on the persons game play, no previous alliances or anything just as if we were starting the game.

Nice question and it's a toughie, lol. If we were in the real survivor the boot list would be;

1st - Jenna (didn't really have any solid allies and probably would annoy the cast, lol.)
2nd - Benry (his head wasn't always in the game and before sides can form, it would be an easy boot.)
3rd - Erinn (even though she is loyal, she wasn't the most social and in survivor it's the most important thing.)
5th - Edgardo (tried to make a move too early but didn't have the following so it backfired.)
5th - Brady (too much of a threat, so they had to take him out before he can do some serious damage.)
6th - Candice (like brady, had to be taken out or else she would make the finals. blindsided.)
7th - Marty (didn't really make that many connections so once it got down to the wire, he was next to go.)
8th - Jeff (went with the flow and loyal to his alliance. could be seen as a threat to win because the jury might be bitter.)
9th - Sydney (strong competitor and had to be taken out right before the finals.)
Finals: Kelly (great personality and had everyone trusting her.) Charlie (competition beast. went on a immunity run to make finals.) Fabio (loyal to his alliance and lead people on leaving him untouched.)

I hope that is what you wanted. Good luck with your decision!

[Erinn Lobdell]

wow so both of you turned against me to please the jury
thx
I'm sorry Edgardo I won't rank anyone
but for the second question
Brady did try to be the leader of the alliance and was deciding the votes for a bit,but then I told Candice about that and that we should vote him out and we should make the decisions not him
Fabio I rarely talked to him so he had no power at all

[Candice Woodcock]

Jan 27, 2011 10:00:36 GMT -5 Erinn Lobdell said:

wow so both of you turned against me to please the jury
thx
I'm sorry Edgardo I won't rank anyone
but for the second question
Brady did try to be the leader of the alliance and was deciding the votes for a bit,but then I told Candice about that and that we should vote him out and we should make the decisions not him
Fabio I rarely talked to him so he had no power at all

I didn't mean to offend you with my answer and if I did then I apologise. I never turned against you to please the jury... it's just based on what people have been saying so I had to rank if this was real survivor.

[Erinn Lobdell]

Jan 27, 2011 14:45:50 GMT -5 Candice Woodcock said:

Jan 27, 2011 10:00:36 GMT -5 Erinn Lobdell said:

wow so both of you turned against me to please the jury
thx
I'm sorry Edgardo I won't rank anyone
but for the second question
Brady did try to be the leader of the alliance and was deciding the votes for a bit,but then I told Candice about that and that we should vote him out and we should make the decisions not him
Fabio I rarely talked to him so he had no power at all

I didn't mean to offend you with my answer and if I did then I apologise. I never turned against you to please the jury... it's just based on what people have been saying so I had to rank if this was real survivor.

well at least you ranked me better than Jenna
the ranking of Kelly is what I hate "You've drawn a lot of negative attention, and I'm afraid people will not tolerate that in a camp."
wow what a reason?you wasn't even with me in the same tribe to know that
and Jenna 5th voted out?WTH

[Fabio Birza]

Erinn, are you trying to lose?

[Erinn Lobdell]

well I wasn't going to win anyway
I am not doing this on purpose, if someone attacks me I won't just shut up and watch

[Sydney Wheeler]

lol<3

[Erinn Lobdell]

is the heart for me or someone else :-P ?

[Sydney Wheeler]

For Benry <3